Les dernières nouvelles de l'économie mondiale (Business) et ses crises. : California

Affichage des articles dont le libellé est California. Afficher tous les articles

mardi 8 juillet 2014

San Francisco Has Become America's Largest Gated Community — And That Is Bad For California

AppId is over the quota
AppId is over the quota
Slate

California is an earthly paradise. Yet there is something badly broken about the Golden State. At its best, California is America’s America, where the young and adventurous go for a fresh start.

The trouble is that housing in much of California has become so expensive that the young and adventurous have been priced out, leaving its most beautiful stretches to wealthy insiders.

Last weekend, I had the great pleasure of visiting the Bay Area, to see friends and to attend a conference. The conference was held in a beautifully-situated resort in Marin County overlooking the Golden Gate Bridge, where a small number of low-rise buildings dotted a pristine landscape.

And I thought to myself, as I often do, that it was insane that this land was not instead dotted by massive high-rises housing thousands of people. The beautiful town of Sausalito has a population of just over 7,000 within its 2¼ square miles. But would it be any less lovely if it were home to twice as many people, or 10 times as many even? Or would it be lovelier still if graceful towers full of young families sprouted on land currently devoted to, of all things, golf courses?

Or consider San Francisco, one of the least-affordable major cities in the United States. San Francisco’s population is about 825,000. If it had the same population density as my hometown, New York City, it would instead have a population of 1.2 million. Note that I’m referring to the population density of all five boroughs of New York City, including suburban Staten Island and the low-rise outer reaches of Brooklyn, Queens, and the Bronx. A San Francisco of 1.2 million would not be a Blade Runner–style dystopia in which mole people were forced to live cheek-by-jowl in blighted tenements. San Francisco at 1.2 million people would still be only half as dense as Paris, a city that is hardly a Dickensian nightmare.

One of the many benefits of allowing for more housing in a city like San Francisco is that it would likely lead to sharp reductions in carbon emissions. San Francisco is among the greenest cities in the United States, thanks largely to its superb climate. The same goes for San Diego, San Jose, and Los Angeles. The economists Edward Glaeser and Matthew Kahn have estimated that a San Francisco household spends one-fourth as much on electricity as a comparable household in Houston, as coastal Californians have far less need for air conditioning. To be sure, California does face serious environmental challenges.

For example, that California’s water resources are stretched thin. But redirecting water resources from agricultural to residential uses would make an enormous difference, as would pricing water resources more intelligently. The environmental upside of supersizing San Francisco and other coastal California cities far outweighs the downside.

So what exactly is the problem? Well, the idea of a much denser San Francisco strikes many residents as appalling, not least because they fear that new development would threaten the city’s distinctive architectural character and the gorgeous views afforded by its stringent land-use regulations.

Shutterstock.com

While I love quirky Victorian houses as much as the next bobo, aesthetic considerations can’t justify the fact that San Francisco has become an oversize gated community.

Rents in San Francisco are three times the national average, and they are rising at a fearsome clip. The housing crisis is even more severe in booming Silicon Valley, where the housing stock has barely increased over the last decade, despite the fact that the region has become a magnet for tech professionals from around the world.

When skyrocketing demand meets stagnant supply, the predictable consequence is that housing costs soar and low- and middle-income families find themselves displaced.

Perhaps you believe, as many otherwise intelligent people do, that the law of supply and demand is somehow inapplicable to the housing market. Consider the following. While San Francisco’s housing stock grew by 8.8 percent between 2000 and 2010, for an average annual growth rate just under 0.9 percent, the average annual growth rate of the housing stock in inner Tokyo was 2 percent. The shocking result is that while rents have been rising rapidly in San Francisco, they’ve been falling, albeit slightly, in Tokyo. If anything, San Francisco should be building far more housing than Tokyo, the capital of a country that is aging rapidly and that welcomes a trivially small number of immigrants.

Rather than allow for more housing development, California’s political class has embraced the campaign to raise the minimum wage. The statewide minimum wage is already set to increase to $10 by July 2016, and labor activists have been pushing to raise it higher still. Not to be outdone by Seattle, Ed Lee, the mayor of San Francisco, has called for a $15 minimum wage for local workers to be put in place by July 2018.

Whether or not minimum wage hikes are the best way to raise incomes (I tend to agree with Slate’s Jordan Weissmann on this issue), it’s worth noting that according to the National Low Income Housing Coalition, you’d need to earn $29.83 an hour to afford a market-rate one-bedroom apartment in San Francisco, or roughly twice Mayor Lee’s proposed minimum wage.

Even the most enthusiastic proponents of minimum-wage increases will generally accept that you’d price some workers out of the labor market at a wage floor twice as high as Seattle’s. Relying solely on minimum wage hikes to make San Francisco housing affordable for local workers will ultimately mean driving all workers who can’t command a high wage out of the local labor market. Does that sound like much of a solution to you?

In The Gated City, Ryan Avent observed that high housing costs in America’s most productive cities had forced large numbers of middle- and low-income households to either accept long, costly commutes, which eat into the ability of families to work and save, or to move to low-cost, low-productivity regions. Over time, this greatly impairs the ability of working- and middle-class Americans to climb the economic ladder.

Moreover, when you move large numbers of people from high-productivity, high-wage regions to low-productivity, low-wage regions, you lower the productivity of the entire country. In other words, the rich homeowners who are fighting development in San Francisco and throughout coastal California are actually making America poorer. That’s not cool.

Go Inside Former Citi CEO Sandy Weill's Breathtaking Home In California Wine Country

AppId is over the quota
AppId is over the quota
Sandy Weill Sonoma Home - Business Insider

Featured Trending Recent Business Insider

Login Remember me I forgot username or password Login with Twitter Login with Facebook Login with LinkedIn Login with Google Register Events BI Intelligence Tech Finance Politics Strategy Life Entertainment All From To You have successfully emailed the post. Finance More: Real Estate Architectural Digest Sandy Weill California Sonoma House Go Inside Former Citi CEO Sandy Weill's Breathtaking Home In California Wine Country

Patricia Leigh Brown, Architectural Digest Jun. 20, 2014, 4:53 PM 3,179 4 facebook linkedin twitter google+ print email print email share share tweet share print email Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linkedin share print email

Sandy Weill Sonoma house Architectural Digest

Sanford I. Weill and his wife, Joan, are über New Yorkers. Known as Sandy, he is the former head of Citigroup and the longtime chairman of Carnegie Hall. She chairs Manhattan’s Alvin Ailey American Dance Theater. Then there is the city’s Weill Cornell Medical College, to which they have donated many millions of dollars. That being said, the Brooklyn-born philanthropists have succumbed to Northern California’s allure and put down roots in Sonoma Valley.

Situated on some 360 rolling acres that include a vineyard—the 2012 Weill a Way red received a 94 on Robert Parker’s 100-point index of excellence—the Weills’ compound is at the end of a vertiginous drive that meanders through fields of sprightly California poppies and live oaks. "We visited in August, four years ago, and the gardeners handed me a plum and a white peach," Joan recalls of their first encounter with the property. "Then the brokers brought us back one night and lit an outdoor fire. That clinched the deal." A year later the couple put their Central Park West penthouse on the market and started packing.

Sandy Weill Sonoma house Architectural Digest

Conceived in the 1990s by Walker & Moody Architects, the firm that masterminded the Auberge du Soleil resort in nearby Rutherford, the Sonoma estate suggests an ancestral enclave in Tuscany. Italian terra-cotta tiles sheathe the higgledy-piggledy roofline of the two-bedroom main residence. A covered breezeway connects that building to a four-bedroom guesthouse—equipped with an indoor pool and a wine library—added by the Weills. There’s also a walled garden overflowing with old-fashioned roses, courtesy of the landscape architect Mai K. Arbegast, who devised the verdant grounds for the property’s previous owners.

Sandy Weill Sonoma house Architectural Digest

To update the interiors, the Weills relied on designer Mica Ertegun, who began working with them on various homes eight years ago. "We were a little intimated by her back then," Sandy says. "Her reputation is so big." Today she is the Weills’ aesthetic alter ego, her portfolio including the couple’s former New York apartment and their villa in the Bahamas. Not only does the decorator share "very similar tastes," with her clients, she describes them admiringly as people who "appreciate that every corner of a home needs to be looked at."

Sandy Weill Sonoma house Architectural Digest

Taking pride of place in the Sonoma main house’s sun-splashed entrance gallery is a 1940s Fernand Léger mosaic whose brilliant blues, yellows, oranges, greens, and reds dance against a light-ocher wall. To accommodate two of the couple’s Thomas Hart Benton paintings, the living room’s carved overmantel was removed, one of several architectural adjustments that Ertegun and John Schaberg, a senior project director at her firm, MAC II, made to the dwelling and its outbuildings. "I’m not a collector," Sandy says modestly. "But I know what I like." And what he likes encompasses everything from the languorous fashion illustration that hangs in the soothingly neutral master bedroom to the giant outdoor sculptures of pink and red roses by Will Ryman. (The overscale blooms were part of a public-art commission installed along ten blocks of Park Avenue in 2011.) When the Weills shop for art, Joan says they both have "the right of refusal"—though, her husband laughingly admits, in the case of the Léger, she lost.

See more of the stunning home >

More From Architectural Digest:

Tom Brady & Gisele Bündchen's Custom Château

Ralph Lauren Shows off His Many Homes

Sandy Weill's Wine Country Estate

The World's Most Radical Houses

facebook linkedin twitter google+ email email share share tweet share email Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linkedin Share on Google Plus email Recommended For You

Join The Discussion OR Login With Facebook Login With Twitter Login With Google Submit the comment for Insider Status Comments Insiders0All Comments4 Apply To Be An "Insider" » Loading

Loading Go Inside Former Citi CEO Sandy Weill's Breathtaking Home In California Wine Country Go Inside Former Citi CEO Sandy Weill's Breathtaking Home In California Wine Country

Sanford I. Weill and his wife, Joan, are...

Get Finance Emails & AlertsLearn More »Finance SelectBusiness Insider SelectMoreFeaturedBusiness Insider SelectBreaking News10 Things Before the Opening BellInstant MBATech Chart Of The DayMarkets Chart Of The DayTech SelectBusiness Insider EventsTechMobile Chart Of The DayScience SelectSocial Media Chart Of The DayEnterprise SelectVideo Chart Of The DayPayments Chart Of The DayE-Commerce Chart Of The DayEntertainmentSports SelectEntertainment SelectFinanceFinancial Advisor InsightsFinance SelectMarkets SelectYour Money SelectSmart InvestorMonday Scouting ReportWealth Advisor SelectLifeLife SelectTransportation SelectEducation SelectStrategyRetail SelectStrategy SelectCareers SelectMarketing MondaysAdvertising SelectAdvertising: The BriefPoliticsPolitics SelectMilitary SelectLaw & Order SelectTop 10 Things10 Things In Tech You Need To KnowClosing BellCharts of the DaySports Chart Of The DayAdvertisement Your Money NASDAQ Composite 4,384 -67.86 (-1.524%) S&P 500 1,963 -14.47 (-0.732%) NYSE Composite 10,954 -81.58 (-0.739%) Sponsored By LinkedIn